Court and Carpenter
Court and Carpenter

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can my commander or OIC order me to answer his questions?


No. Under Article 31, Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ), you cannot be compelled, forced or otherwise “ordered” to talk to anyone, including your commander, about criminal allegations that might later be used against you. If you are suspected of a crime and your chain of command (OSI, CID, NCIS, CGIS, or foreign agents) attempt to speak with you, they must first promptly inform you of your right to consult with a lawyer. If one is not immediately available, you are completely within your constitutional right to remain silent until provided with legal counsel.


How is the military justice system different from the civilian criminal justice system?


The military justice system actually has several advantages over the civilian criminal justice system. Most notably, you have the right to demand an Article 32 hearing prior to a case being referred to a General Court-Martial. This hearing is akin to a federal grand jury proceeding, with one significant addition.  You are free to openly contest the Government’s version of events before the case is even set for trial. Accordingly, you have the right to call witnesses, offer evidence favorable to your case, confront your accuser, discredit the Government’s case, and/or generally offer compelling evidence in mitigation or extenuation that might persuade the convening authority to send your case to a misdemeanor (Special Court-Martial) level court.


If my son is in prison must he be brought to court-martial within a certain period of time?


If your son is in military custody he must be brought to trial within 90 days. If he is out-of-custody, the military has 120 days to bring him to trial after the service of the charges. The Government’s failure to meet the above timelines could result in the dismissal of his charges.


What are the consequences of a court-martial conviction?


First and foremost, a General Court-Martial conviction is the equivalent of a federal civilian felony conviction.  However, if the imposed confinement is less than 1-year certain States “may” regard the conviction as a misdemeanor. Even so, unless your court-martial is overturned on appeal, the conviction will likely remain a permanent part of your civilian record.  Other potential adverse consequences include, but are not limited to: loss of pay, loss of security clearance, loss of health and educational benefits, loss of retirement eligibility, loss of right to travel abroad, loss of right to vote, loss of right to carry a firearm, and in sexual assault cases, the loss of privacy and the significant social stigma associated with sex offender registration.


Can my daughter get the characterization of her discharge changed even after the court-martial?


Each military service has boards that decide upon requests to upgrade and/or vacate both punitive and administrative discharges. Potential available legal remedies, if granted, include changing the reenlistment code to allow reenlistment, improving the characterization of the discharge and/or favorably modifying the narrative reason for the involuntary separation.


What kind of due process will my daughter receive during her administrative separation board?


She has a lot of options and associated rights. She may retain civilian counsel, ask for evidence, call witnesses and seek to discredit the Government’s case. Administrative separation boards are rather informal, but still often play-out as “mini-trials.” Military judges are not appointed to preside of these boards, however. Instead, typically three board members, none of them legally trained, will sit on her case; and ultimately make factual findings and concurrent recommendations. Simply stated, they will decide whether your daughter should be retained in the service. If they decide that she should not, they then recommend the type of discharge she should receive. There are three types of administrative discharges she could receive: an Honorable Discharge, General under Honorable Conditions Discharge; or an Other than Honorable Discharge. Notably, please be mindful she will be able to use her GI Bill only if she receives an Honorable Discharge.


My son has just been sent off to military prison, is he eligible for parole?


The Army Clemency and Parole Board is responsible for handling all claims associated with clemency, parole and mandatory supervised release hearings for eligible prisoners. For instance, in soldier cases Army Regulation 15-130 sets forth the parameters for relief.


Will my son still have the benefit of his military defense counsel even though we have now hired a civilian attorney to help represent him?


Civilian counsel and military defense counsel will often work together on his court-martial case. However, civilian counsel will likely take the lead (termed “first chair”) during the Article 32 hearing, all pre-trial hearings and during most of the trial.


I have heard back from my Informal Physical Evaluation Board, and the result is not good, what can I do next?


You should first make a request for reconsideration. If that proves unsuccessful, then request to appear before a formal board to demonstrate that you are either fit for duty, or deserve a higher disability rating. Expert witness testimony will prove critical in this regard, so make sure to get good experts on your side to clearly demonstrate the merits of your case.  You may also seek review of an adverse decision by the formal board with the Physical Review Counsel, and then finally the Physical Disability Appeal Board.



Court & Carpenter, P.C.

Defending Courts-Martial, Military Appeals & Boards For Active Duty Army, Air Force, Marine Corps, Navy and Coast Guard

CONUS - OCONUS Defense Services with Offices in Seattle & Tacoma, and Kaiserslautern, Germany

Contact us for a toll-free consultation

+1 (833) 446-UCMJ (x8265)


or send us your questions online

1700 Seventh Avenue,

Suite 2100
98101 Seattle

Master Card Visa American Express PayPal
MasterCard, Visa, American Express, Paypal
Druckversion | Sitemap
Every military case presents unique advantages and weaknesses.As such,often the historical results that this firm has enjoyed in representing uniformed members in courts-martial cannot be guaranteed to play-out in any given case. Accordingly, the use of the word "best" is the subjective opinion of this firm and the objective opinions and associated ratings of the renowned attorney evaluation tool (10.0 Superior Rating) (2008-2018) © Monika & Stephen Carpenter